Direct answer
Can a cleaning tablet replace descaler when a coffee machine asks for descaling? Distinguish coffee oils, milk and water circuits
Check the intended purpose first; do not substitute products directly. Coffee-oil cleaning tablets, milk-system cleaners and descalers perform different tasks. Philips CA6704 coffee-oil remover tablets, for example, are explicitly not intended for descaling. Match the product and programme to your machine's prompt, and follow the instructions for the exact model on where to add it, how much to use and how to rinse. Do not copy another machine's method.
Start by identifying what needs removing. Philips' CA6704 instructions concern oil on the brew group's filter, while De’Longhi's descaling guidance concerns mineral scale formed by water inside the machine. An oil-removal clean does not mean descaling has been completed. Philips also provides separate instructions for machines with a pre-ground coffee function, those without it, and those with a Clean menu. Even with the same tablet, checking the machine type remains necessary.
When reading a prompt, look beyond the words on the light. In this Barista Express manual from Breville, a flashing CLEAN/DESCALE light indicates the cleaning backflush programme, while a steady light indicates descaling. The manual treats these as separate programmes with different maintenance products and placement instructions. These light signals apply only to the version covered by this manual. For another machine, check its own display and instructions rather than copying someone else's button sequence or insertion steps.
The milk system has its own programmes too. This edition of the Miele CM 6160, CM 6360 and CM 6560 instructions separately lists milk-system rinsing, milk-system cleaning, brew-unit degreasing and machine descaling. Its milk-system cleaning programme requires the dedicated cleaning solution, prepared as instructed, to be put in the water tank before following the display. The correct placement therefore depends on the specific programme: it is wrong to say that milk-system cleaner never goes in a water tank, but this example does not give permission to do the same with another model.
Hand-washing a component and running a dedicated degreasing programme also need to be distinguished. The Miele manual above requires the brew unit to be washed by hand with warm water, without washing-up liquid or other cleaner. For the degreasing maintenance programme, it instead calls for the specified cleaning tablet and the on-screen instructions. These requirements do not conflict. First establish whether you are hand-washing a part or running the machine's dedicated programme, then use the corresponding method.
Even tablets need to be identified by purpose. The contents of the JURA E8 (NAA) instructions list machine cleaning and machine descaling separately, with milk-system cleaning as another item. When choosing maintenance supplies, check the purpose stated on the packaging and your machine's requirements. Similar appearance, the same brand or a shared place on a maintenance-products shelf does not make them interchangeable.
Maintenance does not end when the product has been added. De’Longhi's guidance requires descaling to follow the machine's prompts and the instructions for the exact model; water-hardness settings and usage affect the maintenance schedule. Complete the rinsing required by the programme as well. Do not invent a dose, waiting time or rinse count for every machine. If a prompt persists or a programme behaves abnormally, consult the relevant instructions or service team rather than repeatedly increasing the amount.
If you are cleaning a separate milk-frothing jug, see the related questions on the jug, whisk and powered base. Permission to wash a frothing jug by hand or in a dishwasher is a different issue from internal coffee-oil removal, milk-system cleaning and descaling in a coffee machine. Identify the appliance and part you are actually using before choosing a care method.

